By clicking
Talk to a Specialist, you agree to our
Privacy Policy. You also consent to receive calls and texts, which may be autodialed, from us and our customer communities. Your consent is not a condition to using our service. Please visit our
Terms of Use. for information about our privacy practices.
For Pittas, the mom - MaryAnn (under 65) entered a HCR (Healthcare and Retirement Corporation of America) owned facility (Liberty Nursing & Rehab) after an auto accident for rehab. At Liberty from 9/07 – 3/08 (6 months / 92K bill, which is 15K a mo rehab cost). She applied for Medicaid & was “Medicaid Pending”. She was under 65 so NO MEDICARE. Then 3/08 she left rehab against medical advice. She left the United States and moved back to Greece (a citizen of) and left before completing the Medicaid application or lawsuit on auto accident. Now the son – upon being billed 92K for his mom’s care - took the situation to an arbitration hearing. (I bet arbitration was required to be done as per admissions contract.) In arbitration, it was ruled in the son’s favor. The son won - he did not have to pay the 92K. HCR appealed the arbitration ruling in son’s favor to a Pennsylvania trial court (judges only, no jury).
From WestLaw: “ As a result, on or about May 12, 2008, HCR instituted a filial support action against Appellant. Pursuant to 23 Pa.C.S.A. § 4603, entitled “Relatives' liability,” HCR sought to hold Appellant liable for the outstanding debt incurred as a result of his mother's treatment and care. The parties submitted the case to arbitration, whereupon a three-member arbitration panel found in favor of Appellant. HCR appealed the arbitration award to the trial court. The trial court held a three-day non-jury trial, after which it entered a verdict in favor of HCR in the amount of $92,943.41. Appellant filed post-trial motions, which the trial court denied on January 13, 2011."
In reading transcripts, my thought is that Pittas & his attorney did a poor job for the trial court - I'd bet they assumed "we won before so we will win again". He did not substantial his bills; did not provide documentation; did not join his father or his sisters for support-burden (if he had, his share would have been 23K - this is the biggest mistake imho); he did not provide documentation to show an attempt at completing the details & documentation needed for mom’s Medicaid application; or pursuing litigation on the auto accident; or bringing her back from Greece. HCR showed the trial court judge, that he had income; Pittas did not show other bills due. If the thought was that he did not have to do anything because he won in arbitration, that was a huge costly mistake.
Most NH situations are not going to be what Pittas was. They are going to be elderly & on MediCARE - so rehab is going to be paid 100% for 21 days and then 80% afterwards up to 100 days by MediCARE. The elder is going to have some $ to pay towards the bill; family is going to make an effort to pay something. If rehab is due to auto accident, your auto policy may pay for some of the costs & if not someone else’s auto insurance is gonna get sued & you are going to follow up on this. You are going to complete the Medicaid application for your parent. And Momma is not going to get up, leave rehab & take a flight to Greece to live!
Many NH have limited # of Medicaid beds and the waiting list for those are from existing residents who have been at the NH private paying for a couple of years. Other NH have Medicaid beds available from day 1. Some NH take NO Medicaid.
NH run between 5K - 12K a mo EACH, so put pen to paper to see where they are likely to run out of funds and need Medicaid. Couple in NH as private pay, I'd say they need 500K to make 2.5 - 3 year average stay in NH. The costs are staggering.
If the property in reality is worth less than the current assessor value, you need to get a licensed registered appraisal of the house done (costs vary, maybe $ 500) & hopefully it shows less value. Then that lower amount should be ok for Medicaid (so no gifting or transfer penalty issues). Appraisal needs to be done by a pro - you can't use Realtor listing price or comps on other property in neighborhood.
If both parents are going into NH at the same time, all will be somewhat easier paperwork for Medicaid. But if dad is going into NH and mom staying @ home as the community spouse, well then it's quite a bit different Medicaid maze to get through as mom becomes the "community spouse" with it's different asset limits
and CSRA/MMNA set up. If one is going to stay in the house, I'd really suggest that before you do anything that you & your parents go see an elder law attorney - perhaps one that is NAELA or CELA, to review planning for both. Good luck.
Now let's say they go into a Nursing Home, sell you the house for $100 and apply for Medicaid. Medicaid sees the sale, it's public record! So Medicaid won't pay a dime. The Nursing Home will sue you and win, because they will allege "hidden assets" and "filial responsibility". See HCRC v. John Pittas.