Siblings disagree with action to take when dad can't afford the place he lives in.

Started by

My husband and I bought a house for my parents when they were having their home repossessed. The agreement was that we would get them into the house and they would be responsible for the house payment, maintenance, utilities and upkeep. My mother died a year later.
Since doing this, we have found out that my dad has nearly depleted all of his savings. I wouldn't be concerned if it were to take a trip or something, but it has been used to keep up with living expenses. Unfortunately, the housing market fell out right after we bought the house, so we owe more on it than it is worth, so refinancing it is not possible. My dad has not been able to pay for the maintenance and upkeep, so my husband and I have been left with this added expense. This has been putting a pinch on us.
We reviewed my dad's (who is 84) financial situation and he only has $170 for food and incidentals after paying the house payment and utilities. This was for an average month. He is spending about $500 more than his income each month. I do have a 40 something brother who lives with him, but he refuses to contribute anything but an occasional pizza or something. We have tried everything to get him to contribute. He has a full time job. At least we know dad is not alone and someone is in and out every 24 hours.
I went to my siblings and told them I thought we needed to move dad to a more affordable place. We also offered any of them to buy the house, at todays market value and interest rate. This should reduce the payment. We are looking at losing $60,000 to $80,000 on this deal. So far nobody is willing to do this. Their solution is for everyone to take on a bill and contribute to a fund to help with repairs. We aren't too comfortable with this as we have asked them to do this, in the past, and nobody would do so. (Their theory was that it was our house and we should take care of it.) Our fear is that they will do it for a couple of months and then stop.
My husband and I cannot afford the house payment and utilities. The maintenance is also draining our savings way down. We have about enough left to pay for all of the moving expenses, move in expenses, make any necessary repairs for selling and pay for a few months of expenses while the house is on the market.
In order to sell the house, we will be having to take money to the table. We can borrow from my husband's parents, to do so, but we need to do so soon, and get it returned, as his dad is in need of being moved to an assisted care facility and they will need the money for that.
Are we being unreasonable to think that moving my dad to a cheaper place would be best? I know he doesn't like the idea and he is 84. I don't like the idea of moving, either, as I am the one who will have to do all of the labor. My dad has a lot of things and is a bit of a pack rat. I am starting to get threatening messages from my siblings. I just don't trust that they will follow through with their contributing and then we will be a year later and dad will be older, he will have no money left, we won't have any money left and we will have lost our resource for a loan to get us out of the house. Please, any solutions and suggestions are welcomed.


I'm all for sitting down with your dad and talking in a matter of fact way. You tell him you don't like seeing him so overwhelmed with trying to keep up the house, and suggest maybe a low income apartment would be the way to go. I think it's logical for you and your husband to do what you want with that house. After all like you said, it is YOUR property. Once dad moves out, then rent the house to a family that can afford the rent and will be good to your house. While it would be nice to think that your siblings are going to rise to the occasion, you'd better have a 'plan B' cause that's probably where you'll end up. Good luck.
I have polished up my crystal ball and tuned it to your frequency. Here is what I see: Siblings cannot be counted on as part of the solution here. Yeah, I know, that is the same conclusion Nancy came to without the fancy equipment, but the crystal ball is so cool I have to use it once in a while.

First, what is good for Dad and is within his means? He might want to stay where he is, but he can't afford it.

Sounds like he might qualify for subsidized senior housing. There is often a waiting list for those (at least here) but the sooner he applies the sooner his name would come up. You'd need a plan for bridging the gap. Could he continue where he is if you know there is an end in sight?

Is Dad at or likely to soon be at a point of needing help with activities of daily living? Would assisted living be suitable? Could he afford that?

It does not sound like Dad needs skilled nursing care, right?

After you come up with a housing option that Dad can afford, then do what you need to do to minimize the losses on the house you bought for Dad to live in (and which he cannot afford at this point). Maybe renting it out does make sense. If the broher who is living there wants to rent it at fair market value I would definitely get a contract the same as you would from any renters!

Remember that some day you and your husband will be old and no longer working. If fact, let us hope you live several decades beyond your retirement. Who/what is going to support you? No matter how much you love Dad it is not a good idea to delete your own savings on his behalf.

Good luck!
Thanks NancyH and JeanneGibbs for your feedback. Dad is still doing well, however, he does have problems with the stairs so he has a chairlift.
So how do we deal with him and the sibling who are uncooperative about moving him? They are telling him not to go and look for a place. I am sure they will tell him not to let any real estate agents in to look at the place. They are threatening legal action. This is getting really ugly. I don't understand why they want him to be humiliated by having to depend on others to support him, not to mention watching my husband and I lose everything. We knew we were getting in financial trouble, but had no idea my dad was having trouble until it was brought to our attention that he has nearly depleted his savings for living expenses. How do I get them to understand that depending on them is not an option for us and that the best thing is to move dad to a place he can afford?
In who's name is the house that dad lives in? What is the name on the title paperwork? and in who's name is the mortgage?

Any idea of what % negative equity in the house?
Family divide, my sympathies to you for what you are going through. I am experiencing my own struggles with trying to get my parents to move to subsidized elderly housing. I at first felt terribly guilty about wanting my parents to make the move but now think that it really is best for the parent to live within his or her means. What I did was to call a family meeting with the local elder agency, which helped a lot. They knew a lot about how to talk with us and they also knew a lot about theirs and outs of the system. Subsidized elder housing has a long wait list, but you could also move him into an apartment until that came through I guess, though multiple moves are far from ideal. Your siblings could be helpful here but instead they are acting out at your expense. -Rose
Thank you igloo572. The house is in my husband and my name. We paid $180,000 for the house and did $10,000 in remodeling, afterwards. The house is worth about $60,000 to $80,000 less, now. Hard to know for sure until it is put on the market.
The house is in your name. You certainly can do with it what you choose. What on earth are your sibs threatening legal action over?!
Familydivided. Did you have a family meeting and were all siblings on board with the purchase of this home? Is this your home and your mortgage? Only in your names?

Your intentions were honorable but the result is a disaster for you. The bank only cares about who is on the mortgage. If this is totally your home, it will be up to you and your husband to get rid of the home or work out a plan with your siblings to divide up the money owed each month to keep you father in the home. Sad, situation.

If the siblings are not legally bound to the home and they are not likely to help with expenses each month, you have no option other than to get rid of the home. At this point you are looking at financial ruin if this continues, not to speak of mental anxiety.

In this market, I know of several situations that have turned sour for several families. In one the couple is looking at a short sale. This may be your better choice. Anyway you cut it, if you sell the house you will lose money at this point. And depending upon your siblings to pay for the upkeep and billing monthly is probably wishful thinking.

if I were you, I would look to salvage what you can and prepare for your future. Your father may have to look into other, cheaper options. But your heart was in the right place. Good luck to you
So, this is your house and yours alone. Your siblings have no right to threaten or make you feel bad about trying to salvage your financial situation. They have not one legal leg to stand on.Your father has no claim to this home unless he is on the mortgage, nor does your brother who lives there.

I feel sorry for your father, however, he was not honest with you from the beginning about his financial situation. After all he was having a home repossessed. That should have been a red flag.

As they say, no good deed goes unpunished.
FamD - OK this isn't going to be very kum-ba-ya but here's my take.
- first, stop thinking of the house as a home but as a piece of PROPERTY. This helps in getting rid of the emotional baggage with all this.

- second, try not to borrow from your DH's family for this. Who knows you may need to ask them for something a couple of years from now.

- third, Dad has shown that he is totally irresponsible in the past with having a house repo'd. Now I'm assuming that this was a mobile home rather than a traditional home which would go via a foreclosure. He doesn't get what ownership entails and never has and never will. His staying at the property will only lessen the value of this investment. He has got to go. Same for the brother. You are enabling a situation that will not turn around for the better and could cause long term financial issues for you and your patience of a saint DH.

I'd give him 60 days and then he's out as the property is going to be sold. Tell him in clear terms and also in writing. This is between Dad and you & your DH as owners of the property. If Dad takes it up with your siblings, then that is his issue. Rather than put him on the street, I'd take whatever he is supposed to pay for rent & against the mortgage for 2 months and use it to pay for 1 mo rental & 1 mo deposit and pay to move him in and therefore out of the property. Or if you are feeling generous, you pay for the deposit and 1 mo rent and therefore he has extra money to deal with month 3 & 4. Make copies of the checks and all documents as you know there will be blowback. Find someplace simple, accessible and inexpensive but do NOT sign off as the financially responsible party.Contact your Agency on Aging to see what might be available. He might do well at a board & care style of home. Change the locks on all at the property.

- fourth - find a couple of Realtors to evaluate the situation as far as comps and days on market and what you need to do (and spend even more $$ on) to make it sellable. Personally, and this is tough, if you are negative equity on the property at 30% and the comps aren't looking good and days on market is in months rather than days, I'd just walk away from it and let it go into foreclosure.

I'm assuming the property is not in anyway companionized to the home that you & your DH have, so a foreclose doesn't matter to that mortgage. Now if it is then you are stuck with it. A short sale like Madge said could work but they tend to take forever so you have to constantly goose the mortgage holder to get paperwork through. Whatever the case, a good Realtor will help you keep your sanity.

- fifth - my guess is that your siblings are envious of you. You can't fight that if it is the situation as that is their emotional baggage.

Lastly, when dealing w/difficult family, I have found, that we (women) can either be the witch of the east or the witch of the west but we never ever can be Glinda the good witch no matter what. Just do what is best for you and your DH 1st.

Keep the conversation going (or start a new one)

Please enter your Comment

Ask a Question

Reach thousands of elder care experts and family caregivers
Get answers in 10 minutes or less
Receive personalized caregiving advice and support