Elder Fraud or Paranoia Caused by Dementia

14 Comments

 Print

Email Email

 

Sometimes, people are stealing from a person with Alzheimer's or dementia, thinking they can get away with it since the person has a failing memory. And the person with dementia is rarely believed.

Elders are Vulnerable

Think about that vulnerability. I equate it with a small child in school having to defend herself against a teacher. Who do people tend to believe? The adult. The teacher. But what if the teacher is lying?

Right now, in my home town, there is a couple on trial for signing the woman's father's name to a very large loan guarantee. The father has Alzheimer's. The rest of the family says he was not capable of knowing what he was signing, if indeed he did sign it. And, they think it may be a forged signature. Please realize, no crime has yet been proven. The couple took very good care of the father. He lacked for nothing, according to stories about the incident. What will happen next is up to the courts.

However, we all have heard of times when elders have been swindled. Elder fraud is almost an industry in and of itself. Elders are vulnerable, and often get ripped off by scam artists. They give out their account information to "a nice young man" who wants donations for cancer research, and afterwords, they may find their checking account empty. But that scenario is much different than an elder who doesn't' remember that she set her sweater down in the bathroom, so she accuses a caregiver of stealing it.

Can You Believe Accusations From a Person with Dementia?

So, who is right when an elder says someone is stealing their money or belongings? Is there a nursing home that can claim an employee has never stolen from an elder? An assisted living center? Of course the good ones guard against that with background checks and experienced employees. But still, this crime can and does happen. There are dishonest people working in every industry.

 
 

Comments

 
  •  Comments 1 to 10 of 14 
 
 

leahtown

Give a Hug

Sep 17, 2008

I loved this blog, Carol. I can relate to some of it myself. I know how important a belonging can be. I know how frustrating it is when it is not where I expect it to be. My husband will sometimes get my phone out of my purse or get my gameboy to recharge them (since I cannot remember to do it.) Whenever I go to use either of these things and they are not where they should be, I panic. "What could I have done with them? Where could I have left them? How will I ever find them?" Never do I think, 'Oh, Bill must have taken it to be recharged..." No, I never remember to think that! I know how good it feels to where a special piece

 
 

denise

Give a Hug

Sep 18, 2008

My Mom started accusing me of stealing from her bank accounts when I started taking care of her, after my Dad Passed away. She would tell EVERYONE I was stealing. I was turned into Adult Protective services! Of course, I was not guilty, she just was not getting the same retirement money she got when Dad was living. I had to make a budget for her to show her excatly what her bills are and what her income is. And update and explain her checkbook often. I still have the budget on hand so she can see it all in black and white. Adult Protective services dropped the case, but still might check up. Thanks MOM.:) (Jokingly)

 
 

Denise, I came close to where you went! I was accused, as well, when my mother got everything she wanted. It's so scary. You know you are innocent, but with people protecting vulnerable elders (as they should), sometimes you are guilty until proven innocent. That's why I advise people repeatedly to keep good records. That helps immensely.

Take care,
Carol

 
 

Leah - How wonderful to find you here! Folks, Leah is a gifted writer, and she has the insight of having vascular dementia and what it's like to live with this. You will love her posts, and they will help you understand another side of these events. Leah is one of the bravest and most helpful people I've ever known. She was - and is - a terrific educator.

Carol

 
 

GinaConte

Give a Hug

Sep 19, 2008

This is so common among people with dementia! We have a woman right now at the assisted living place where I work that is telling other residents that her mothers ring has been stolen among other prized possessions. In actuality the son took these things home to keep them safe and she can't remember that. But I have also known of cases where things are actually stolen. It is devastating to a family to find out the heirloom ring that was to be handed down to the granddaughter is gone when the resident passes. I despise theft of any kind from vulnerable elders. The only thing the facilities can do is to do the background checks and be vigilant about following up when someone says something was stolen, dementia or not. Find out if that family member took that ring home for sure. And family needs to keep on eye on valuables, even getting a separate safe to put them in or take them home for safe keeping. There is no easy answer.

 
 

You're right about no easy answer, as the elder often doesn't want to give up the jewelry. My mother-in-law had a lovely diamond set, and I didn't even notice when it was gone, but somewhere it disappeared. I don't know if one of her kids took it home, or if it got lost or stolen, but I was asked about it, when she died. I'd forgotten she had it on when she went to the nursing home. It was a natural part of her. Her kids didn't visit often, so some employee may have thought she didn't have any family, even though I was there every day. But she lost weight, and the rings could have simply gotten lost.

Elders lose so many rights, that it's hard to say to someone, "Now that you are in a facility, you need to leave your rings in a safe place." They aren't likely to go for that. Yet, things do get stolen. It's a very difficult quandry. Like so many areas of elder care - there are no easy answers, and there is no one-size-fits-all solution.
Carol

 
 

Mgrady1

Give a Hug

Sep 20, 2008

Yes, this is a dilema- however in my case with my mother (whose was in a nursing home), I didn't beleieve her when she told me they were mean to her and stealing things. i thought she was just trying to make me feel bad and i believed the staff when they put the blame on my mother. However, after 15 months my mother got a new roommate and that roommate told me they were mean to her. i pulled my mother out of that nursing home immediately and took care of her in my home. my mother died a year later- my biggest regret is that i didn't believe her and that i didn't rescue her sooner.

 
 

That is exactly the problem. There's no easy way to know. Don't blame yourself - you did what felt right at the time, and your thoughts were totally plausible.
I over-reacted once in a nursing home setting and got a guy in trouble when it was my dad's dementia talking. This CNA was an angel anyway, and what he did for my mother, after my dad died, was wonderful. It's just so hard to tell.

However, when in doubt, we need to do what we can to investigate. Visiting at odd times sometimes can help. It's good your mom had a roommate to tattle. It almost sounds as if they targeted your mom, or the roommate would have complained about her own treatment. That's really odd.

Good for you for taking action.
Carol

 
 

Marie

Give a Hug

Dec 18, 2008

Today my mom called and said 6 sweather were stolen from her room. She thinks it was the cleaning lady. We had a similiar problem last year. It turns out her medication at the time was depleteing her sodium level. She had been fine for almost a year

 
 

I'm glad you found out it was the medication. It could be she needs an adjustment again, or it could be the worsening of symptoms. Whatever it is, my heart goes out to you. I've been there.
Carol

 
  •  Comments 1 to 10 of 14 

Add Your Comment

Find Senior Housing And Care That Fits You Needs

I am looking for:
Search location:











Housing


Care


Stay Connected

Sign up for our newsletter and receive practical tips and support for caregivers

 

Like AgingCare.com on Facebook